A “Modified Draft” for America: “Bankruptcy Lottery”

It’s Memorial Day, a day to honor those who’ve served our nation and protected the freedom we cherish.  So to all the veterans and to those still in harm’s way today as active-duty personnel, we salute you.

For most Americans, it’s all too easy to forget that we’re still at war.  Those actually doing the fighting, suffering, and dying are increasingly demographically concentrated, and even geographically concentrated.  There aren’t a whole lot of wealthy kids from Greenwich dodging bullets over in Afghanistan.  For that matter, the number of middle class kids over there is disproportionately low, when compared to the poor and working class.

The problem with this is that the people making the decision to go to war and stay at war are not the ones bearing the cost of war.  In economics, this is known as the “principal-agent problem,” i.e., where those making decisions are not the ones incurring the cost.  A waiter, for example, may decide to give a huge (and unprofitable) portion to a patron, figuring, “hey, the owner’s gonna pay, so no skin off my apple… and it might even increase my tip!”

In a restaurant, this is a problem.  But when it comes to war-making, it’s catastrophic.  If most Americans don’t have to bear the costs of war, they don’t properly value it — i.e., they don’t fully internalize just how shitty it is.  For too many Americans, the war in Afghanistan has been reduced to cool war footage on TV.   So why should there be any urgency in ending it?

If there were a draft — one with no deferments — is it likely that this war would’ve reached its 12th year?  If kids were being plucked out of the blue for service, without regard to race/wealth/location, would America have stood for this?  I think not.

We’re not going to have a draft any time soon.  America wouldn’t stand for it.   But what about a modified version?  Some other way for all Americans to feel some pain when our troops are at risk?

I humbly suggest the “bankruptcy lottery.”

The way it would work is simple:  For every day we’re at war, and for every soldier killed or wounded, an American would be picked at random for instant bankruptcy.  All their assets would be seized.  House, car, cash, Swiss bank accounts, everything.  Instantly.   Back to zero.

Would that suck?  You better believe it.  But it pales in comparison to what our troops risk every day.

No doubt, this would make news, and the stories of those selected for bankruptcy would be spread far and wide in this, the 24-hour news cycle.  And most likely, it would scare the crap out of folks, as they saw newly bankrupt people who “look just like me!”

And maybe that would give them just a teeny, itsy bitsy sense of the true cost of war, and make us as a society “price” it more appropriately.

And hell, if we’re not even willing to endure a one-in-a-million chance of losing our earthly possessions, we certainly shouldn’t be eager to send our troops to risk something far more valuable.

Advertisements

About John Hlinko

John Hlinko is a frequent political pundit on TV, and the founder of Left Action, a network of over 1 million activists. He is also the author of, "Share, Retweet, Repeat: Get Your Message Read and Spread," ranked by Amazon.com as the # 1 "hot new release" in web marketing in early 2012. Follow him on Twitter and Facebook
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to A “Modified Draft” for America: “Bankruptcy Lottery”

  1. Tom Casto says:

    I would suggest changing the bankruptcy to a draft of a random person to replace that soldier that has paid the ultimate price with their life. No deferment, no argument, and after proper training send them off to that god forsaken place.

  2. Paulhaider74 says:

    Afghanistan has become the new Vietnam in its similar loss of American assets and resources; there is nothing to show for our effort…with the exception of death and debt. We will surpass the length of the Vietnam War (1964-1975) in October of 2012 with our eleventh year in Afghanistan, and this continues to be a “rich man’s war and a poor man’s fight” with the manner in which it was initiated by two millionaires (Bush and Cheney) whose own daughters have spent a total length of zero days/hours/minutes/seconds in that foreign country; this is appropriate given that their fathers spent the exact same amount of time in Vietnam during the 1960’s and 1970’s. I recommend for only a targeted bankruptcy of the Bush and Cheney families, and then we should replace Dickhead Cheney’s new heart with a grenade; this would serve as a symbol for the war(s) that he started.
    Paul Haider, Chicago

  3. I think you’ve hit the nail on the head – wish I’d thought of it.

  4. FrankHenry says:

    The draft is a good idea, it should :

    1. Be not only of our 18 year olds.
    2. Be conducted evey year during peace and war.
    3. Be a minimum of 20% draftees should be drawn each year.
    4. Have 10% of the draftees should be drawn from the pool of ALL elected
    and appointed officials including (fed, state, local).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s